Successfully blind the Kraken in the The Kraken's Eye event without making any mistakes

As The Witch, use a Potion of Overboarding to throw yourself overboard

Encounter the Wasp Nest event twenty-five times

Play a Traits+ Game

As The Manipulator, force another pirate to throw you overboard

As The Retaliator, throw a pirate who voted for you overboard

As The Psychic, correctly predict which pirate will next go overboard in a The Psychic's Prediction event

As The Traders, trade traits while occupying the Captain and Stowaway ranks